Purchased in 2024. This is a creamy, richly pigmented brown lip liner. I loved it so much that I bought a lot of them and have some in stock. I'm selling these because my makeup style has changed. This is a set of three. It's a deep, clear chocolate brown color. It's soft and creamy, easy to apply, and easy to blend. The color also lasted well. No individual sales. No price reduction. Instant purchase OK. Thank you for looking.