This item is listed as "defective" because it has been size-adjusted. A 16.5 size is usually a Japanese L, but the sleeves and length have been shortened, making it closer to a size S-M. Please judge based on the actual measurements, and if the size fits, it's a bargain. Because the length is short, it can be worn outside of your pants. There are a few faint stains, but they are not very noticeable (photos 6-9). This item is for those who are accustomed to vintage clothing and have no objections. I've worn many Brooks Brothers button-down shirts for 40 years, and I still prefer the American-made ones. The roll of the collar and the looseness of the body are different from the Asian-made ones. Even the store staff don't know the reason. If I had to say, it has the affluent feel and rugged dignity of old, good America. Even if the collar is slightly frayed from wearing it without a tie, the white T-shirt peeking out from the open roll of the collar somehow makes you look like a good person. ▪️Size (approximate actual measurements) Length: 75cm Sleeve Length: 52cm Width: 57cm ▪️Color White