I've only used these shoes once, so they're very clean with no scratches or wear on the soles. However, as you can see in the sixth image, there is a slight stain on the sock part. It's barely noticeable, but please be aware of this. The color of the socks is also very cute, and they look great with the silver shoes! They should fit someone who usually wears a size 23.5. Comes with the box. In short, these are adorable ballet flats with cute socks! #Beams #RayBeams #UnitedArrows #ZARA