Both are beautiful. I bought the pink one, which had been worn once, and dressed my child in it once. I bought the red one, which was either only tried on or worn once, and dressed my child in it once. I don't think there's much sign of wear, and they are beautiful items. There is some slight pilling due to being stored at home. As seen in photos 6 and 7, there are some color variations in the check pattern, which I believe was there originally. Because it's a check pattern, I may overlook small stains or dirt, so please only purchase if you can accept this. I would prefer to sell them together.