The one on the left is a soft material, and the one on the right is a smooth material. The black one has been used less than 5 times. I think the one on the right has been used less than 20 times. I'm decluttering because I have a lot of bags. When shipping, I will fold them in half. *I am also selling on other sites, so there may be cases where the item is out of stock. Please leave a comment to check availability before purchasing.