Thank you for viewing! (❁ᴗ͈ˬᴗ͈) These are black formal shoes with ribbons from Biofitter. As shown in the photos, there is a scratch near the fastener on the left shoe. The removable ribbon is attached, but one is coming loose. It can be used as is if you sew it back on. I used them once for an entrance ceremony about two years ago, and they have been stored in the box ever since. They will be shipped without the box.